Complete scenario rehearsal
Your unit must advise on a service change next week. Two teams disagree about the cause of delays, the data covers only a short period, and staff capacity is already tight. How would you prepare advice and organise follow-up?
Say your own answer before opening the example.
Reveal the worked response
I would first define the decision needed and confirm the service outcome and deadline with the responsible manager. I would compare the teams’ evidence, check how the delay measure was collected and identify what the short observation period cannot establish. I would map the process handoffs and ask each team for examples of cases affected, while keeping personal information protected. I would present realistic options using common criteria: expected effect, staff capacity, cost, user access, risk and reversibility. If the evidence is incomplete, I would distinguish a low-risk trial from a permanent change and state what approval each requires. I would assign named owners for data checks and operational planning, agree a reporting date and make unresolved questions visible. In the brief, I would state my recommendation, assumptions and downside, then explain how results would be reviewed. This gives the manager a decision they can make with a clear view of evidence and trade-offs.
Try the follow-up questions
- What would you do if one team refused to provide the underlying figures?
- How would you protect service delivery while testing a change?
Check your answer
- Did I define the decision, evidence limits and service outcome?
- Did I include staff capacity and user impact in the comparison?
- Did I assign owners and state how the decision will be reviewed?